The hazards of dealing with response time outliers

The presence of outliers in response times can affect statistical analyses and lead to incorrect interpretation of the outcome of a study. Therefore, it is a widely accepted practice to try to minimize the effect of outliers by preprocessing the raw data. There exist numerous methods for handling outliers and researchers are free to choose among them. In this article, we use computer simulations to show that serious problems arise from this flexibility. Choosing between alternative ways for handling outliers can result in the inflation of p-values and the distortion of confidence intervals and measures of effect size. Using Bayesian parameter estimation and probability distributions with heavier tails eliminates the need to deal with response times outliers, but at the expense of opening another source of flexibility.