Comparative Efficacy of Endogenous Stem Cells Recruiting Hydrogels and Stem Cell-loaded Hydrogels in Knee Cartilage...

Cartilage defects remain a challenge in diseases such as osteoarthritis (OA) and fractures. Scientists have explored the use of hydrogels in conjunction with stem cell technology as a tissue engineering method to treat cartilage defects in joints. In recent years, research into hydrogels containing stem cell technology for cartilage repair has mainly focused on two categories: stem cell-loaded hydrogels and endogenous stem cell recruiting hydrogels. The latter, utilizing cell-free products, represents a novel concept with several advantages, including easier dose standardization, wider sources, and simpler storage. This meta-analysis aims to assess and compare the therapeutic effects of endogenous stem cell recruiting hydrogels and stem cell-loaded hydrogels in promoting articular cartilage regeneration in animal models, with the goal of exploring endogenous stem cell recruiting hydrogels as a promising replacement therapy for knee cartilage regeneration in preclinical animal studies.

We systematically searched PubMed, Web of Science, Cochrane Library, and Embase until January 2023 using key words related to stem cells, cartilage regeneration and hydrogel. A random-effects meta-analysis was performed to evaluate the therapeutic effect on newborn cartilage formation. Stratified analyses were also carried out by independently classifying trials according to similar characteristics. The level of evidence was determined using the GRADE method.

Twenty-eight studies satisfied the inclusion criteria. Comprehensive analyses revealed that the use of endogenous stem cell recruiting hydrogels significantly promoted the formation of new cartilage in the knee joint, as evidenced by the histological score (3.77, 95% CI 2.40, 5.15; p < 0.0001) and the International Cartilage Repair Society (ICRS) macroscopic score (3.00, 95% CI 1.83, 4.18; p = 0.04), compared with the control group. The stem cell-loaded hydrogels also increased cartilage regeneration in the knee with the histological score (3.13, 95% CI 2.22, 4.04; p = 0.02) and the ICRS macroscopic score (2.49, 95% CI 1.16, 3.82; p = 0.03) in comparison to the control. Significant heterogeneity between studies was observed, and further stratified and sensitivity analyses identified the transplant site and modelling method as the sources of heterogeneity.

The current study indicates that both endogenous stem cell recruiting hydrogels and stem cell loaded hydrogels can effectively promote knee joint cartilage regeneration in animal trials.