Compendium of Chromatographic Behavior of Post-translationally and Chemically Modified Peptides in Bottom-Up...

We have systematically evaluated the chromatographic behavior of post-translationally/chemically modified peptides using data spanning over 70 of the most relevant modifications. These retention properties were measured for standard bottom-up proteomic settings (fully porous C18 separation media, 0.1% formic acid as ion-pairing modifier) using collections of modified/nonmodified peptide pairs. These pairs were generated by spontaneous degradation, chemical or enzymatic treatment, analysis of synthetic peptides, or the cotranslational incorporation of noncanonical proline analogues. In addition, these measurements were validated using external data acquired for synthetic peptides and enzymatically induced citrullination. Working in units of hydrophobicity index (HI, % ACN) and evaluating the average retention shifts (ΔHI) represent the simplest approach to describe the effect of modifications from a didactic point of view. Plotting HI values for modified (y-axis) vs nonmodified (x-axis) counterparts generates unique slope and intercept values for each modification defined by the chemistry of the modifying moiety: its hydrophobicity, size, pK_a of ionizable groups, and position of the altered residue. These composition-dependent correlations can be used for coarse incorporation of PTMs into models for prediction of peptide retention. More accurate predictions would require the development of specific sequence-dependent algorithms to predict ΔHI values.