Investigation of Feature Engineering Methods for Domain-Knowledge-Assisted Bearing Fault Diagnosis
Christoph Bienefeld1,2, Florian Michael Becker-Dombrowsky1, Etnik Shatri1,2
1Institute for Product Development and Machine Elements, Technical University of Darmstadt, Otto-Berndt-Straße 2, 64287 Darmstadt, Germany.
Entropy (Basel, Switzerland)
|September 28, 2023
Summary
This study enhances rolling bearing fault diagnosis by combining domain knowledge with feature engineering and random forest classification. Frequency band separation achieved high accuracy and efficiency, offering explainable results superior to deep learning.
Area of Science:
- Mechanical Engineering
- Data Science
- Machine Learning
Background:
- Rolling bearing condition monitoring is crucial for industrial machinery.
- Traditional methods often rely on vibration data and machine learning for fault diagnosis.
- Deep learning methods are gaining popularity for their data-driven approach, reducing the need for domain expertise.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate the effectiveness of traditional feature engineering methods combined with domain knowledge for rolling bearing fault diagnosis.
- To evaluate novel combinations of signal processing techniques and mathematical feature formulas.
- To compare the performance of feature engineering approaches against purely data-driven deep learning methods.
Main Methods:
- A comprehensive feature engineering study involving 42 mathematical feature formulas.
- Application of preprocessing methods including envelope analysis, empirical mode decomposition, wavelet transforms, and frequency band separations.
- Utilizing a random forest classifier for fault prediction and evaluation on the CWRU bearing fault dataset.
Main Results:
- Feature calculation using frequency band separation yielded particularly high prediction accuracies.
- The proposed feature engineering method demonstrated high efficiency with low computational effort.
- The approach provided excellent accuracies comparable to deep learning methods, with the added benefit of explainability.
Conclusions:
- Feature engineering combined with domain knowledge offers a robust and explainable alternative for rolling bearing fault diagnosis.
- Frequency band separation is a highly effective preprocessing technique for this application.
- The proposed method presents a competitive and interpretable solution compared to complex deep learning models.
Related Concept Videos
Bearings: Problem Solving
301
Understanding the calculations and concepts related to double-collar bearings is essential for engineers and designers to optimize the performance of these components in various applications. By analyzing the bearing under different conditions, one can ensure that it can withstand the forces and moments experienced during operation. This knowledge enables better decision-making when designing and selecting bearings for specific purposes and configurations. Consider a double-collar bearing with...
301
Journal Bearings
699
Journal bearings are mechanical components that support and provide lateral stability to rotating shafts and axles. They are crucial in reducing friction, wear, and vibration in machinery such as engines, turbines, and pumps. The principle behind journal bearings is forming a thin lubricant film between the bearing surface and the rotating shaft, which minimizes direct contact and reduces frictional forces.
To better understand the concept of journal bearings, consider a rope winch with dry or...
To better understand the concept of journal bearings, consider a rope winch with dry or...
699
Bearing Stress
920
Bearing stress refers to the contact pressure between two separate bodies. To visualize this, imagine a bolt thrust through a plate. The bolt applies a force to the plate, which exerts an equal but opposite force back onto the bolt. This force isn't just a singular entity but a compilation of numerous smaller forces distributed across the contact surface between the bolt and the plate.
Due to the intricacy of these microforces, an average value, known as bearing stress, is often used by...
Due to the intricacy of these microforces, an average value, known as bearing stress, is often used by...
920
Collar Bearings
1.3K
Collar bearings are essential in various machines designed to support axial loads on rotating shafts. Depending on the specific application and requirements, they can be found with single or multiple collars.
1.3K
Transmission Shafts: Problem Solving
258
Designing a solid shaft that transmits power from a motor to a machine tool involves a series of calculations to ensure the shaft can withstand the stresses applied by bending moments and torques. First, calculate the torque exerted on the gear, considering the power transmitted by the shaft and its rotational speed. Following this, compute the tangential forces acting on the gears, which directly relate to the torque and the gear radius.
Next, use bending moment diagrams for the shaft to...
Next, use bending moment diagrams for the shaft to...
258
Pivot Bearings
1.3K
In mechanical systems, bearings are crucial in facilitating relative motion between two components while minimizing friction and wear. They help distribute various loads (radial, axial or a combination of both loads) across machinery parts, ensuring smooth and efficient operation.
A pivot bearing is a specialized type of bearing designed to support axial loads on a rotating shaft. The bearing surface, or the pivot, is positioned at the end of a shaft to support the axial thrust. The pivot may...
A pivot bearing is a specialized type of bearing designed to support axial loads on a rotating shaft. The bearing surface, or the pivot, is positioned at the end of a shaft to support the axial thrust. The pivot may...
1.3K


