Gender diversity in neurosurgical training: an analysis of trends and resident program characteristics

Recent trends have shown more women entering neurosurgery, but large gender gaps in the number of female trainees continue to persist. A previous study on the gender diversity of residents and faculty in neurosurgery training programs found that only 18.2% of residents and 8.7% of faculty at neurosurgical training programs were female. The goal of this study was to better understand program characteristics that may affect the recruitment of female residents and the gender composition of neurosurgery residency programs.

The authors assessed publicly available information on websites and social media from 116 Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME)-accredited neurosurgery residency programs from the 2022-2023 academic year. Data collected on residents included gender and postgraduate year (PGY), geographic region, accreditation year, and complement size for programs. The authors analyzed the distribution of female residents at each program and compared accreditation year, program size, program geographics, PGY, and acceptance rates.

There were 1602 residents across the 116 programs included in this study: 1223 (76.3%) male and 379 (23.7%) female residents. The gender distribution of female residents showed 29 programs had 30% or more female residents, 50 programs had between 16% and 30%, and 37 had fewer than 16%, including 8 with none. There were significantly more PGY-1 than PGY-7 female residents (28.9% vs 16.4%, p < 0.01). Programs with ACGME accreditation before 1970 had significantly higher percentages of female residents (26.0%) compared with those accredited after 1970 (18.2%, p < 0.01). Program size was associated with a higher percentage of female residents (large = 25.2%, medium = 24.9%, and small = 19.6%), although the results were not significant. The distribution of female trainees across five geographic regions of the United States was fairly even: Northeast (24.5%), West (25.2%), South Atlantic (23.1%), South Central (21.8%), and North Central (21.2%). Residency acceptance rates were similar between genders.

The underrepresentation of women in neurosurgery residency programs remains a significant issue. While some programs have achieved higher female representation than the overall average proportion of female neurosurgery residents, many still fall short. There are twice as many female PGY-1 compared with PGY-7 residents, suggesting increased recruitment over the past few years. Programs with longer accreditation histories have significantly higher proportions of female residents. Larger program size can also play a role in attracting more female residents, but geographic location did not impact gender composition of resident cohorts in this study.