Mutagenicity of 43 structurally related heterocyclic compounds and its relationship to their carcinogenicity

43 heteropolycyclic compounds belonging to a homologous series were investigated for mutagenicity. The results are compared with carcinogenicity data obtained with the same batches of compounds under conditions identical for all of them. Mutagenicity was tested in the Ames test with Salmonella typhimurium strains TA1535, TA1537 and TA100 in the presence and absence of liver 10 000 g supernatant from rats treated with Aroclor 1254. Carcinogenicity was tested by injection of the compounds into subcutaneous tissue of XVIInc/Z mice. 18 test compounds showed carcinogenic activity, some strongly, others only weakly. Of these, 17 were detected as mutagens: one weak carcinogen did not revert the Salmonella strains. No quantitative correlation was observed between the extents of the mutagenic and the carcinogenic effects. Of the 25 substances that did not produce tumours, 13 showed mutagenicity (12 in the presence, 2 in the absence, of the liver homogenate). The mutagenic effects of these compounds were quantitatively similar to those of the compounds that produced tumours. The most sensitive strain of Salmonella typhimurium was TA100. It detected all 30 mutagens. TA98 was mutated by 25 compounds, TA1537 by 16 compounds. No mutagenic effects were seen with TA1535. Possible reasons for the high percentage of apparently "false positives" in the Ames test and the lack of a quantitative correlation between the potency of the mutagenic and carcinogenic effects are discussed. It is suggested that the complexity of the metabolism of these heterocyclic compounds may lead to critical differences in metabolism in mouse subcutaneous tissue in vivo and in liver homogenates from rats treated with Aroclor. Therefore the present study will be extended to life-long oral and intrahepatic carcinogenicity tests leading to a higher proportion of metabolism in the liver.