Determinants of respiratory muscle weakness in stable chronic neuromuscular disorders

In neuromuscular disease, the precise relationship between general and respiratory muscle weakness is at present unclear. That relationship and the influence on respiratory muscle strength of such factors as type and duration of neuromuscular disease, distribution of general muscle weakness, and nutritional status were studied in 30 patients with stable chronic neuromuscular disease not presenting with respiratory symptoms. The degree of general muscle weakness was assessed by clinical examination of the strength of 17 muscle groups, yielding a general muscle strength index. The degree of respiratory muscle weakness was assessed by measuring maximal static inspiratory and expiratory mouth pressures. Maximal inspiratory (mean +/- SD: 68 +/- 28 percent predicted) and expiratory (66 +/- 29 percent predicted) mouth pressures were frequently reduced, but did not correlate with general muscle strength. The ability to estimate the degree of respiratory muscle weakness improved to some extent when the type of neuromuscular disease and the distribution of general muscle weakness were taken into account: thus, maximal expiratory mouth pressure was significantly lower (p less than 0.05) in myopathy than in polyneuropathy, and in proximal than in distal muscle weakness. Duration of neuromuscular disease and nutritional status did not influence respiratory muscle strength. It is concluded that in stable chronic neuromuscular disease, respiratory muscle involvement depends on a complexity of factors, in particular the type of neuromuscular disease and the distribution, rather than the degree, of general muscle weakness. In the individual patient, however, only direct measurement of maximal inspiratory and expiratory mouth pressures allows accurate assessment of respiratory muscle strength. These tests ought to complement neurologic examination.