Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jul 9, 2025
Author Spotlight: A Comprehensive Protocol for Acinetobacter Biofilm Quantification, Assessment, and Visualization
Published on: August 4, 2023
Bacterial viability in dry-surface biofilms in healthcare facilities: a systematic review
A-J Schapira1, M Dramé2, C Olive3
1CHU Martinique, Department of Bacteriology, Hygiene and Environment Laboratory, Fort-de-France Cedex, Martinique; Paris Cité University, Faculty of Health, Paris, France.
Background:
Bacteria are known to live inside architectural structures called biofilms. Though standard biofilms have been studied extensively for more than 50 years, little is known about dry-surface biofilms (DSBs). Since 2012, DSBs have been described in several scientific papers, but basic knowledge about the viability and culturability of bacteria remains limited.
Aim:
To conduct a systematic review to determine whether bacteria inside DSBs are viable, culturable, and enumerable.
Methods:
Eligible articles had to deal with DSBs containing at least one bacterial species involved in healthcare-associated infections, which developed in actual healthcare environments (in-situ) or with the help of any biofilm model (in-vitro).
Findings:
Twenty-four articles were included in the review. Whereas most of them isolated viable bacteria (87% in situ; 100% in vitro), no in-situ study quantified culturable bacteria in the biofilm per unit area. Conversely, 100% of in-vitro studies cultured the bacteria from controls and 94.4% supplied an enumeration of them. Culturable bacteria also grew after 78% of the cleaning, disinfection, or sterilization protocols tested. Microscopic observations after staining the samples with live/dead fluorescent probes (Baclight®) showed large amounts of viable cells in culture-negative samples.
Conclusion:
Our study questions the efficacy of current methods for microbiological monitoring of surfaces, since these methods are only based on bacterial culturability. To improve both surface monitoring and cleaning and disinfection protocols, it is necessary to integrate the concept of DSBs which appears to contain a significant amount of viable but non-culturable bacteria.
