The case of Geneviève Lhermitte's euthanasia between psychiatric evaluation, legal aspects and ethical reflection

A recent euthanasia case in Belgium has garnered attention due to its particularly dramatic aspects, sparking clinical and ethical questions about end-of-life choices in cases of mental suffering. A 56-year-old woman, convicted of the murder of her five minor children and sentenced to life imprisonment, has been granted euthanasia for "irreversible psychological suffering". The clinical and psychodynamic aspects of the case, primarily deduced from press reports, are highly complex and give rise to numerous clinical, medico-legal, and bioethical questions. These include inquiries into the true nature of psychopathology, its actual irreversibility, its impact on the ability to express a euthanasia request with adequate awareness, the preserved capacity for self-determination, and broader issues related to end-of-life requests from patients with mental disorders. These aspects are considered in the context of the legislation in various European countries. The unique details of this case underscore the critical challenges associated with these complex issues.