Closer look at the calorimetric lower transition in lipid bilayers

The thermal behavior of unilamellar vesicles has been revisited with differential scanning calorimetry to address the issue of whether it is essential to include interactions between neighboring bilayers in theories and simulations of the ripple phase. The issue focuses on the lower, aka pretransition, and the ripple phase that clearly exists between the lower and main transitions in multilamellar vesicles (MLV). We find anomalous thermal behavior in unilamellar vesicles (ULV) beginning at the same temperature as the lower transition in MLVs, but this feature is considerably broadened and somewhat weaker compared to the lower transition in MLVs. We ascribe this to the difficulty of packing a regular ripple pattern on small spheres. In agreement with a few reports of a ripple phase in direct images of single bilayers, we conclude that interactions between neighboring bilayers are not essential for the ripple phase in lipid bilayers.