Comparative formation of chlorinated and brominated disinfection byproducts from chlorination and bromination of...

Amino acids are the main components of dissolved organic nitrogen in algal- and wastewater-impacted waters, which can react with chlorine to form toxic halogenated disinfection by-products (DBPs) in the disinfection process. In the presence of bromide, the reaction between amino acids and secondarily formed hypobromous acid can lead to the formation of brominated DBPs that are more toxic than chlorinated analogues. This study compares the formation of regulated and unregulated DBPs during chlorination and bromination of representative amino acids (AAs) (e.g., aspartic acid, asparagine, tryptophan, tyrosine, and histidine). In general, concentrations of brominated DBPs (trihalomethanes, haloacetonitriles, and haloacetamides, 24.9-5835.0 nM) during bromination were higher than their chlorinated analogues (9.3-3235.3 nM) during chlorination. This indicates the greater efficacy of bromine as a halogenating agent. However, the formation of chlorinated haloacetic acids during chlorination was higher than the corresponding brominated DBPs from bromination. It is likely that an oxidation pathway is required for the formation of haloacetic acids and chlorine is a stronger oxidant than bromine. Moreover, chlorine forms higher levels of haloacetaldehydes (74.4-1077.8 nM) from amino acids than bromine (1.0-480.2 nM) owing to the instability of brominated species. The DBP formation yields depend on the types of functional groups in the side chain of AAs. Eight intermediates resulting from chlorination/bromination of tyrosine were identified by triple quadrupole mass spectrometer, including N-chlorinated/brominated tyrosine, 3-chloro/bromo-tyrosine, and 3,5-dichloro/dibromo-tyrosine. These findings provided new insights into the DBP formation during the chlorination of algal- and wastewater-impacted waters with elevated bromide.