Fragment-based models for dissociation of strong acids in water: Electrostatic embedding minimizes the dependence on...

Fragmentation methods such as MIM (Molecules-in-Molecules) provide a route to accurately model large systems and have been successful in predicting their structures, energies, and spectroscopic properties. However, their use is often limited to systems at equilibrium due to the inherent complications in the choice of fragments in systems away from equilibrium. Furthermore, the presence of charges resulting from any heterolytic bond breaking may increase the fragmentation error. We have previously suggested EE-MIM (Electrostatically Embedded Molecules-In-Molecules) as a method to mitigate the errors resulting from the missing long-range interactions in molecular clusters in equilibrium. Here, we show that the same method can be applied to improve the performance of MIM to solve the longstanding problem of dependency of the fragmentation energy error on the choice of the fragmentation scheme. We chose four widely used acid dissociation reactions (HCl, HClO4, HNO3, and H2SO4) as test cases due to their importance in chemical processes and complex reaction potential energy surfaces. Electrostatic embedding improves the performance at both one and two-layer MIM as shown by lower EE-MIM1 and EE-MIM2 errors. The EE-MIM errors are also demonstrated to be less dependent on the choice of the fragmentation scheme by analyzing the variation in fragmentation energy at the points with more than one possible fragmentation scheme (points where the fragmentation scheme changes). EE-MIM2 with M06-2X as the low-level resulted in a variation of less than 1 kcal/mol for all the cases and 1 kJ/mol for all but three cases, rendering our method fragmentation scheme-independent for acid dissociation processes.