Molecular testing in newborn screening: VUS burden among true positives and secondary reproductive limitations via...

Expanded carrier screening (ECS) gene panels have several limitations, including variable content, current knowledge of disease-causing variants, and differing reporting policies. This study evaluated if the disease-associated variants identified in affected neonates who screened positive by California newborn screening (NBS) for an inherited metabolic disorder (IMD) by tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) would likely be reported by ECS gene panels.

Retrospective review of neonates referred by the California Department of Public Health for a positive NBS by multianalyte MS/MS from January 1, 2020 through June 30, 2021.

One hundred thirty-six neonates screened positive for ≥1 NBS MS/MS indication. Nineteen neonates (14%) were ultimately diagnosed with an IMD, all of whom had abnormal biochemical testing. Eighteen of the 19 underwent molecular testing; 10 (56%) neonates had ≥1 variants of uncertain significance, 9 of whom were of non-White ancestry. ECS panels would have been negative for 56% (20/36) of parents with an affected neonate, 85% (17/20) of whom were of non-White ancestry.

The number of variants of uncertain significance identified in this cohort highlights the need for more diversified variant databases. Due in part to the lack of diversity in currently sequenced populations, genomic sequencing cannot replace biochemical testing for the diagnosis of an IMD.