Likelihood of sampling prostate cancer at systematic biopsy as a function of gland volume and number of cores

Pre-biopsy multiparametric magnetic resonance imaging (mpMRI) of the prostate is used to conduct targeted prostate biopsy (TB), guided by ultrasound and registered (fused) to the MRI. Systematic biopsy (SB) continues to be used together with TB or in mpMRI-negative patients. There is insufficient evidence on how to use SB to inform clinical decision-making in the mpMRI era. The purpose of this study was to estimate the effect of prostate volume and number of SB cores on sampling clinically significant prostate cancer (csPCa) using a simulation method based on clinical data.

SBs were simulated using data from 42 patients enrolled in a transrectal ultrasound robot-assisted biopsy trial. Linear mixed models were used to examine the relationship between the number of SB cores and prostate volume on 1) clinically significant cancer detection probability (csCDP) and 2) percent of mpMRI depicted regions of interest (ROIs) sampled with the SB.

Median values and interquartile range (IQR) were 47.16 cm³ (35.61-65.57) for prostate volume, 0.57 cm³ (0.39-0.83) for ROI volume, and 4.0 (2-4) for PI-RADS v2.1 scores on MRI. csCDP increased with the increasing number of simulated SB cores and decreased substantially with larger prostate volume. Similarly, the percent of ROIs sampled increased with the increasing number of simulated SB cores and was lower for prostate volumes ≥60 cm³ compared to glands <60 cm³.

The effect of the number of SBs performed on detecting csPCa varies largely with gland volume. The common 12-core SB can achieve adequate cancer detection and sampling of ROIs in smaller glands, but not in larger glands. In addition to TB or in mpMRI-negative patients, the number of SB cores can be adjusted to prostate volume. Performing 12-core SB alone in ≥60 cm³ glands results in inadequate sampling and potential PCa underdiagnosis.