The Diagnostic Utility of Repeat Fine-needle Aspirations of Benign Thyroid Nodules

Objective This study aims to analyze the diagnostic utility of multiple repeat FNA on thyroid nodules with initially benign diagnosis. Methods In a 5-year period, 1658 thyroid nodules with initially benign FNAs were retrospectively reviewed and followed for subsequent resection and repeat biopsy. Results Out of 2150 thyroid nodules, 1658 (77.1%) were diagnosed as benign on FNAs. The average age was 57.4 years (range 11-93 years), and most were females (83.8%). Repeat FNA was performed on 183 benign nodules, of which 141 (8.5%) were sampled a second time and 42 (2.5%) had 2 or more repeat samplings. For the benign nodules without repeat FNAs, 124 had benign resection. Of cases with one-time repeat FNA, most (n=101) remained benign on repeat FNAs, 13 of which were benign on resection. Eleven had atypical repeat FNAs, 5 were resected, 4 of which were benign and one was atypical follicular neoplasm with HRAS and TERT promoter mutations. Of cases with multiple repeat FNA, most (n=35) were still benign on repeat FNAs, one had benign resection. Two had atypical repeat biopsies, one was PTC on resection with CCD6::RET fusion. The positive predictive value significantly decreased from 41.1% on single FNA to 8.3% on one-time repeat (p<0.001) and 16.7% on multiple repeat (p=0.002). The total cost for workup of previously benign nodules was $285,454. Conclusions Repeat FNA biopsies did not provide an additional diagnostic value in the evaluation of benign thyroid nodules, and often led to unwarranted follow-up procedures and significantly increased health care cost.