Inadequate (Ax) Transbronchial Lung Transplant Biopsies-Scope and the Potential Contributing Factors

Transbronchial biopsy is the cornerstone for the evaluation of graft function after lung transplant and a standard of care to diagnose acute cellular rejection. However, the yield from these biopsies is variable, with about 15% to 50% of samples being judged as nondiagnostic, leading to additional procedures. The factors contributing to the nondiagnostic sampling have not been delineated, and the discordance in sample assessment between the bronchoscopist and pathologist has not been quantified.

A retrospective cohort of patients who had bronchoscopies with biopsies for surveillance and graft assessment at a large-volume transplant center was studied. The occurrence of nondiagnostic alveolar sampling was assessed, and the patient demographics and procedural characteristics were compared with the diagnostic group.

We included 128 patients in our study and found the inadequacy rate for alveolar tissue sampling to be 15.5%. The median number of passes made by the bronchoscopist was 9, and the number of samples assessed by the bronchoscopist was 8, with a median of 6 adequate samples identified by the pathologist. The frequency of previous biopsies, history of prior inadequate samples, need for a higher number of pass attempts, presence of airway abnormalities, and the use of general anesthesia increased the odds of inadequate sampling.

Patients with the identified factors may be at risk of inadequate sampling on transbronchial biopsies. The bronchoscopist could consider getting additional samples to avoid a nondiagnostic alveolar sample. Further multicenter studies would help to elucidate other contributing factors.