Hand hygiene in a clinical setting: Evaluation of an electronic monitoring system in relation to direct observations

This study evaluated the accuracy of an electronic monitoring system for assessing hand hygiene in a clinical setting in relation to direct observations.

An electronic monitoring system was installed in a surgical ward at a tertiary hospital in Sweden. Hand hygiene events registered by the system were compared with direct observations conducted simultaneously by a trained observer following the World Health Organization's "My five moments for hand hygiene". A 4-step protocol was developed to evaluate the system's ability to accurately monitor hand hygiene in a clinical setting.

A total of 947 opportunities for hand hygiene were observed during June to December 2019. Of these, 484 opportunities were correctly captured by the electronic monitoring system and included in the calculations for accuracy. Sensitivity was 90.2% with a positive predictive value of 95.7%, while specificity was 50.0% with a negative predictive value of 29.0%. Overall accuracy was 87.1%.

Evaluating technical systems assessing hand hygiene in clinical settings is hampered by several challenges. The 4-step protocol helped to identify the limitations and strengths of the evaluated electronic monitoring system, revealing high accuracy while also detecting system errors.