Environmental Sustainability of Lighter Fluids

Lighter fluids are consumer products used only at a low-volume scale, representing a realizable goal of fossil fuel replacement by renewables. Physicochemical properties of four fossil-based conventional lighter fluids (Ronsonol, Zippo, Landmann, and Terracotta) and six selected biomass-based chemicals (γ-valerolactone, ethyl-levulinate, ethanol, n-butanol, γ-valerolactone 90% v/v and ethanol 10% v/v, and ethyl-levulinate 90% v/v and ethanol 10% v/v mixtures) as potential biomass-based lighter fluids were assessed. Assessments were carried out in terms of safety, toxicological, and environmental viewpoints, represented by a flash point, boiling point, vapor pressure values, and evaporation rates; oral toxicity measured on rats; and real ethanol equivalent values, respectively. Parameters were collected where available; in the absence of literature data, they were calculated or measured and then analyzed. Finally, multicriteria analysis based on the flash point, boiling point, vapor pressure, toxicity, and ethanol equivalent values revealed γ-valerolactone as a renewable substance, which can be a promising alternative to replace fossil-based lighter fluids because it was awarded as the first in the multicriteria evaluation by obtaining the highest value of the overall scores. In practical usage, however, ignition, combustion experiments, flue gas, and emission analysis are also required to underline its commercial use in the future.