Compliance With Federal Price Transparency Rules and Cost Estimation at United States Hospitals With Neurosurgical...

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services implemented federal requirements on January 1, 2021, under the Public Health Service Act that require hospitals to provide a list of payer-negotiated prices or "standard charges" in a machine-readable file and in a patient-friendly online estimator for standard services. We sought to assess compliance by United States hospitals associated with neurosurgical training programs with these federal requirements for 11 common neurosurgical procedures.

We performed a cross-sectional analysis in March 2023 of 116 United States hospitals associated with a neurosurgical training program to assess compliance with the new federal requirements to have a machine-readable, downloadable file with standard charges and a patient-friendly online estimator for two spinal procedures.

A total of 110/114 (96.5%) hospitals were compliant with the requirement for a machine-readable file with payer-negotiated prices. A total of 47/110 hospitals (42.7%) were compliant with downloadable machine-readable files and reported at least one payer-negotiated price for 1 of the 11 common neurosurgical procedures. A total of 45/110 (40.9%) used bundled Diagnosis-Related Group codes, and 18/110 (16.4%) did not contain any price information for neurosurgical procedures. For neurosurgical procedures, the percent difference between the average negotiated private insurance and Medicare price per procedure ranged from 17.5% to 77.6%. Medicare and private insurance data for each procedure were available on average for 10.3 states (SD = 3.8) and 15.6 states (SD = 4.8), respectively.

While hospital compliance with federal requirements for machine-readable files with payer-negotiated prices was high, availability of payer-negotiated prices for 4 major insurance types across 11 common neurosurgical procedures based on Current Procedural Terminology codes was sparce. Consequently, meaningful conclusions on procedure-related charges for elective procedures are difficult for patients to make because of the unintelligible format of data and a lack of reporting of charges per Current Procedural Terminology code in a comprehensive manner.