Modulation of Cullin-RING E3 ubiquitin ligase-dependent ubiquitination by small molecule compounds

Cullin (CUL)-RING (Really Interesting New Gene) E3 ubiquitin (Ub) ligases (CRLs) are the largest E3 family. The E3 CRL core ligase is a subcomplex formed by the CUL C-terminal domain bound with the ROC1/RBX1 RING finger protein, which acts as a hub that mediates and organizes multiple interactions with E2, Ub, Nedd8, and the ARIH family protein, thereby resulting in Ub transfer to the E3-bound substrate. This report describes the modulation of CRL-dependent ubiquitination by small molecule compounds including KH-4-43, #33, and suramin, which target the CRL core ligases. We show that both KH-4-43 and #33 inhibit the ubiquitination of CK1α by CRL4^CRBN. However, either compound's inhibitory effect on this reaction is significantly reduced when a neddylated form of CRL4^CRBN is used. On the other hand, both #33 and KH-4-43 inhibit the ubiquitination of β-catenin by CRL1^β-TrCP and Nedd8-CRL1^β-TrCP almost equally. Thus, neddylation of CRL1^β-TrCP does not negatively impact the sensitivity to inhibition by #33 and KH-4-43. These findings suggest that the effects of neddylation to alter the sensitivity of CRL inhibition by KH-4-43/#33 is dependent upon the specific CRL type. Suramin, a compound that targets CUL's basic canyon, can effectively inhibit CRL1/4-dependent ubiquitination regardless of neddylation status, in contrast to the results observed with KH-4-43/#33. This observed differential drug sensitivity of KH-4-43/#33 appears to echo CUL-specific Nedd8 effects on CRLs as revealed by recent high-resolution structural biology efforts. The highly diversified CRL core ligase structures may provide opportunities for specific targeting by small molecule modulators.