Evaluating the Impact of the Tamm-Dancoff Approximation on X-ray Spectrum Calculations

The impact of the Tamm-Dancoff approximation (TDA) for time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) calculations of X-ray absorption and X-ray emission spectra (XAS and XES) is investigated, showing small discrepancies in the excitation energies and intensities. Through explicit diagonalization of the TDDFT Hessian, XES was considered by using full TDDFT with a core-hole reference state. This has previously not been possible with most TDDFT implementations as a result of the presence of negative eigenvalues. Furthermore, a core-valence separation (CVS) scheme for XES is presented, in which only elements including the core-hole are considered, resulting in a small Hessian with the dimension of the number of remaining occupied orbitals of the same spin as the core-hole (CH). The resulting spectra are in surprisingly good agreement with the full-space counterpart, illustrating the weak coupling between the valence-valence and valence-CH transitions. Complications resulting from contributions from the discretized continuum are discussed, which can occur for TDDFT calculations of XAS and XES and for TDA calculations of XAS. In conclusion, we recommend that TDA be used when calculating X-ray emission spectra, and either CVS-TDA or CVS-TDDFT can be used for X-ray absorption spectra.