Subgroup identification-based model selection to improve the predictive performance of individualized dosing

Currently, model-informed precision dosing uses one population pharmacokinetic model that best fits the target population. We aimed to develop a subgroup identification-based model selection approach to improve the predictive performance of individualized dosing, using vancomycin in neonates/infants as a test case. Data from neonates/infants with at least one vancomycin concentration was randomly divided into training and test dataset. Population predictions from published vancomycin population pharmacokinetic models were calculated. The single best-performing model based on various performance metrics, including median absolute percentage error (APE) and percentage of predictions within 20% (P20) or 60% (P60) of measurement, were determined. Clustering based on median APEs or clinical and demographic characteristics and model selection by genetic algorithm was used to group neonates/infants according to their best-performing model. Subsequently, classification trees to predict the best-performing model using clinical and demographic characteristics were developed. A total of 208 vancomycin treatment episodes in training and 88 in test dataset was included. Of 30 identified models from the literature, the single best-performing model for training dataset had P20 26.2-42.6% in test dataset. The best-performing clustering approach based on median APEs or clinical and demographic characteristics and model selection by genetic algorithm had P20 44.1-45.5% in test dataset, whereas P60 was comparable. Our proof-of-concept study shows that the prediction of the best-performing model for each patient according to the proposed model selection approaches has the potential to improve the predictive performance of model-informed precision dosing compared with the single best-performing model approach.