Beyond Encapsulation: Exploring Macrophage-Fibroblast Cross Talk in Implant-Induced Fibrosis

The foreign body response (FBR) and organ fibrosis are complex biological processes involving the interaction between macrophages and fibroblasts. Understanding the molecular mechanisms underlying macrophage-fibroblast cross talk is crucial for developing strategies to mitigate implant encapsulation, a major cause of implant failure. This article reviews the current knowledge on the role of macrophages and fibroblasts in the FBR and organ fibrosis, highlighting the similarities between these processes. The FBR is characterized by the formation of a fibrotic tissue capsule around the implant, leading to functional impairment. Various factors, including material properties such as surface chemistry, stiffness, and topography, influence the degree of encapsulation. Cross talk between macrophages and fibroblasts plays a critical role in both the FBR and organ fibrosis. However, the precise molecular mechanisms remain poorly understood. Macrophages secrete a wide range of cytokines that modulate fibroblast behavior such as abundant collagen deposition and myofibroblast differentiation. However, the heterogeneity of macrophages and fibroblasts and their dynamic behavior in different tissue environments add complexity to this cross talk. Experimental evidence from in vitro studies demonstrates the impact of material properties on macrophage cytokine secretion and fibroblast physiology. However, the correlation between in vitro response and in vivo encapsulation outcomes is not robust. Adverse outcome pathways (AOPs) offer a potential framework to understand and predict process complexity. AOPs describe causal relationships between measurable events leading to adverse outcomes, providing mechanistic insights for in vitro testing and predictive modeling. However, the development of an AOP for the FBR does require a comprehensive understanding of the molecular initiating events and key event relationships to identify which events are essential. In this article, we describe the current knowledge on macrophage-fibroblast cross talk in the FBR and discuss how targeted research can help build an AOP for implant-related fibrosis. Impact statement Biomaterials are widely used to manufacture medical devices, but implantation is associated with a foreign body response (FBR), which may lead to failure of the implants. Surface properties are related to FBR severity. In this review, we zoom in on the cross talk between the two key players, macrophages and fibroblasts, and propose the use of Adverse Outcome Pathways to decipher the causal link between material properties and the severity of the FBR. This approach will help increase a mechanistic understanding of the FBR and, thus, aid in the design of immunomodulatory implant surfaces.