Structural instability and linear allocation control in generalized models of substance use disorder

Substance use disorder (SUD) is a complex disease involving nontrivial biological, psychological, environmental, and social factors. While many mathematical studies have proposed compartmental models for SUD, almost all of these exclusively model new cases as the result of an infectious process, neglecting any SUD that was primarily developed in social isolation. While these decisions were likely made to facilitate mathematical analysis, isolated SUD development is critical for the most common substances of abuse today, including opioid use disorder developed through prescription use and alcoholism developed primarily due to genetic factors or stress, depression, and other psychological factors. In this paper we will demonstrate that even a simple infectious disease model is structurally unstable with respect to a linear perturbation in the infection term - precisely the sort of term necessary to model SUD development in isolation. This implies that models of SUD which exclusively treat problematic substance use as an infectious disease will have misleading dynamics whenever a non-trivial rate of isolated SUD development exists in actuality. As we will show, linearly perturbed SUD models do not have a use disorder-free equilibrium. To investigate management strategies, we implement optimal control techniques with the goal of minimizing the number of SUD cases over time.