Suitability of Gelatin Methacrylate and Hydroxyapatite Hydrogels for 3D-Bioprinted Bone Tissue

Complex bone defects are challenging to treat. Autografting is the gold standard for regenerating bone defects; however, its limitations include donor-site morbidity and increased surgical complexity. Advancements in 3D bioprinting (3DBP) offer a promising alternative for viable bone grafts. In this experiment, gels composed of varying levels of gelatin methacrylate (GelMA) and hydroxyapatite (HA) and gelatin concentrations are explored. The objective was to increase the hydroxyapatite content and find the upper limit before the printability was compromised and determine its effect on the mechanical properties and cell viability.

Design of Experiments (DoE) was used to design 13 hydrogel bioinks of various GelMA/HA concentrations. These bioinks were assessed in terms of their pipettability and equilibrium modulus. An optimal bioink was designed using the DoE data to produce the greatest stiffness while still being pipettable. Three bioinks, one with the DoE-designed maximal stiffness, one with the experimentally defined maximal stiffness, and a literature-based control, were then printed using a 3D bioprinter and assessed for print fidelity. The resulting hydrogels were combined with human bone-marrow-derived mesenchymal stromal cells (hMSCs) and evaluated for cell viability.

The DoE ANOVA analysis indicated that the augmented three-level factorial design model used was a good fit (p < 0.0001). Using the model, DoE correctly predicted that a composite hydrogel consisting of 12.3% GelMA, 15.7% HA, and 2% gelatin would produce the maximum equilibrium modulus while still being pipettable. The hydrogel with the most optimal print fidelity was 10% GelMA, 2% HA, and 5% gelatin. There were no significant differences in the cell viability within the hydrogels from day 2 to day 7 (p > 0.05). There was, however, a significantly lower cell viability in the gel composed of 12.3% GelMA, 15.7% HA, and 2% gelatin compared to the other gels with a lower HA concentration (p < 0.05), showing that a higher HA content or print pressure may be cytotoxic within hydrogels.

Extrusion-based 3DBP offers significant advantages for bone-tissue implants due to its high customizability. This study demonstrates that it is possible to create printable bone-like grafts from GelMA and HA with an increased HA content, favorable mechanical properties (145 kPa), and a greater than 80% cell viability.