Phenotypic differentiation despite gene flow: Beak morphology, bite performance, and population genetics of...

Previous studies of Loggerhead Shrikes (Laniidae: Lanius ludovicianus) in North America have indicated considerable intraspecific genetic and phenotypic differentiation, but the congruence between genetic and phenotypic differentiation remains obscure. We examined phenotypic differences in beak shape and bite force among geographic groupings across a 950 km range, from the lower Imperial Valley to the upper Central Valley of California, USA. We integrated these analyses with a population genetic analysis of six microsatellite markers to test for correspondence between phenotypic and genetic differences among geographic groups. We found significant phenotypic differentiation despite a lack of significant genetic differentiation among groups. Pairwise beak shape and bite force distances nevertheless were correlated with genetic (F _ST) distances among geographic groups. Furthermore, the phenotypic and genetic distance matrices were correlated with pairwise geographic distances. Takentogether, these results suggest that phenotypic differences might be influenced by neutral processes, inbreeding (as indicated by high heterozygosity deficiencies we observed), local adaptation, and/or phenotypic plasticity.