Nanocrystal residual strains and density layers enhance failure resistance in the cleithrum bone of evolutionary...

Failure-resistant designs are particularly crucial for bones subjected to rapid loading, as is the case for the ambush-hunting northern pike (Esox lucius). These fish have slim and low-density osteocyte-lacking bones. As part of the swallowing mechanism, the cleithrum bone opens and closes the jaw. The cleithrum needs sufficient strength and damage tolerance, to withstand years of repetitive rapid gape-and-suck cycles of feeding. The thin wing-shaped bone comprises anisotropic layers of mineralized collagen fibers that exhibit periodic variations in mineral density on the mm and micrometer length scales. Wavy collagen fibrils interconnect these layers yielding a highly anisotropic structure. Hydrated cleithra exhibit Young's moduli spanning 3-9 GPa where the yield stress of ∼40 MPa increases markedly to exceed ∼180 MPa upon drying. This 5x observation of increased strength corresponds to a change to brittle fracture patterns. It matches the emergence of compressive residual strains of ∼0.15% within the mineral crystals due to forces from shrinking collagen layers. Compressive stresses on the nanoscale, combined with the layered anisotropic microstructure on the mm length scale, jointly confer structural stability in the slender and lightweight bones. By employing a range of X-ray, electron and optical imaging and mechanical characterization techniques, we reveal the structure and properties that make the cleithra impressively damage resistant composites. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: By combining structural and mechanical characterization techniques spanning the mm to the sub-nanometer length scales, this work provides insights into the structural organization and properties of a resilient bone found in pike fish. Our observations show how the anosteocytic bone within the pectoral gridle of these fish, lacking any biological (remodeling) repair mechanisms, is adapted to sustain natural repeated loading cycles of abrupt jaw-gaping and swallowing. We find residual strains within the mineral apatite nanocrystals that contribute to forming a remarkably resilient composite material. Such information gleaned from bony structures that are different from the usual bones of mammals showcases how nature incorporates smart features that induce damage tolerance in bone material, an adaptation acquired through natural evolutionary processes.