Long-term outcome of surgically treated and conservatively managed Rathke cleft cysts

Rathke cleft cysts (RCC) are benign lesions of the sellar region that require surgical treatment in case of visual deterioration or progression of the cyst. However, the natural course is often stable and asymptomatic. We aimed to investigate the characteristics of patients with cyst progression during follow-up (FU) and to compare the natural history of patients with RCC with patients who underwent surgery.

Patients with an MR morphologic cystic sellar lesion classified as RCC between 04/2001 and 11/2020 were included. Functional outcomes, including ophthalmologic, endocrinologic, and MRI data, were retrospectively analyzed and compared between surgically treated patients, patients on a "watch and wait" strategy (WWS), and patients on a WWS who underwent secondary surgery due to cyst progression.

One hundred forty patients (median age 42.8 years) with RCC on MRI were identified. 52/140 (37.1%) underwent primary surgery. Of 88 patients (62.9%) with initial WWS, 21 (23.9%) underwent surgery for secondary cyst progression. Patients on the WWS had significantly smaller cyst volumes (p = 0.0001) and fewer visual disturbances (p = 0.0004), but a similar rate of hormone deficiencies (p = 0.99) compared with surgically treated patients preoperatively. Postoperatively patients suffered significantly more often from hormone deficiencies than WWS patients (p = 0.001). Patients who switched to the surgical group were significantly more likely to have preoperative T1 hyperintense signals on MRI (p = 0.0001) and visual disturbances (p = 0.001) than patients with continuous WWS. Postoperatively, these patients suffered more frequently from new hormonal deficiencies (p = 0.001). Endocrine and ophthalmologic outcomes in patients with primary and secondary surgery were comparable. Multivariate analysis showed that WWS patients were at a higher risk of requiring surgery for cyst progression when perimetric deficits (p = 0.006), hyperprolactinemia (p = 0.003), and corticotropic deficits (p = 0.005) were present.

Surgical treatment of RCC may cause new hormonal deficiencies, which are rare in the natural course. Therefore, the indication for surgery should be carefully evaluated. Hyperprolactinemia and corticotropic deficits were significant indicators for a secondary cyst progression in patients with RCC. However, a significant amount of almost 25% of initially conservatively managed cysts showed deterioration, necessary for surgical intervention.