Participation of electrochemically inserted protons in the hydrogen evolution reaction on tungsten oxides

Understanding the mechanisms by which electrodes undergo the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) is necessary to design better materials for aqueous energy storage and conversion. Here, we investigate the HER mechanism on tungsten oxide electrodes, which are stable in acidic electrolytes and can undergo proton-insertion coupled electron transfer concomitant with the HER. Electrochemical characterization showed that anhydrous and hydrated tungsten oxides undergo changes in HER activity coincident with changes in proton composition, with activity in the order HWO₃·H₂O > HWO₃ > HWO₃·2H₂O. We used operando X-ray diffraction and density functional theory to understand the structural and electronic changes in the materials at high states of proton insertion, when the oxides are most active towards the HER. H_0.69WO₃·H₂O and H_0.65WO₃ have similar proton composition, structural symmetry, and electronic properties at the onset of the HER, yet exhibit different activity. We hypothesize that the electrochemically inserted protons can diffuse in hydrogen bronzes and participate in the HER. This would render the oxide volume, and not just the surface, as a proton and electron reservoir at high overpotentials. HER activity is highest in HWO₃·H₂O, which optimizes both the degree of proton insertion and solid-state proton transport kinetics. Our results highlight the interplay between the HER and proton insertion-coupled electron transfer on transition metal oxides, many of which are non-blocking electrodes towards protons.