Applicability of self-consistent reaction field (SCRF) method to DFT estimation of hydrogen isotope separation...

In earlier quantum chemical calculations of isotope effects, chemical species in the liquid phase were generally treated as existing in the gas phase. In recent years, however, advances in computational programs have made it easier for the self-consistent reaction field (SCRF) method to handle chemical species in the liquid phase, and as a result, it has become easier to apply the SCRF method to isotope effect calculations. This paper concerns the scope of application of the DFT-SCRF method to reversible processes for hydrogen isotope enrichment. It is found that the applicability of the method depends on the type of the intermolecular interaction in the liquid phase and the degree of hydrogen isotope effect (separation factor) on which the process is based. When the magnitude of the isotope effect of the separation system is greater than 10^-1, the simple SCRF method is fully applicable; when the magnitude is around 10^-2, SCRF with a dimer model, in which the monomer is replaced by a dimer, is applicable for the analysis of the liquid phase with relatively strong intermolecular interactions. Anharmonic correction to the separation factor calculated based on harmonic frequencies may be effective to systems with the liquid phase with weak intermolecular interactions.