Lessons learned and new strategies for success: Evaluating the Implementation of Competency-Based Medical Education...

In 2017, Queen's University launched Competency-Based Medical Education (CBME) across 29 programs simultaneously. Two years post-implementation, we asked key stakeholders (faculty, residents, and program leaders) within the Pediatrics program for their perspectives on and experiences with CBME so far.

Program leadership explicitly described the intended outcomes of implementing CBME. Focus groups and interviews were conducted with all stakeholders to describe the enacted implementation. The intended versus enacted implementations were compared to provide insight into needed adaptations for program improvement.

Overall, stakeholders saw value in the concept of CBME. Residents felt they received more specific feedback and monthly Competence Committee (CC) meetings and Academic Advisors were helpful. Conversely, all stakeholders noted the increased expectations had led to a feeling of assessment fatigue. Faculty noted that direct observation and not knowing a resident's previous performance information was challenging. Residents wanted to see faculty initiate assessments and improved transparency around progress and promotion decisions.

The results provided insight into how well the intended outcomes had been achieved as well as areas for improvement. Proposed adaptations included a need for increased direct observation and exploration of faculty accessing residents' previous performance information. Education was provided on the performance expectations of residents and how progress and promotion decisions are made. As well, "flex blocks" were created to help residents customize their training experience to meet their learning needs. The results of this study can be used to inform and guide implementation and adaptations in other programs and institutions.