A Comparison of Mini Open Transverse Incision and Longitudinal Incision for the Release of Moderate and Severe Carpal...

Carpal tunnel syndrome is a common condition seen in daily clinical practice. Multiple minimally invasive techniques have emerged in the last decades for median nerve decompression. However, many research are needed to study the outcome on the patients and their safety profile.

We will compare group A that includes patients operated on using the minimally invasive transverse incision (number of patients = n = 221, females 76.7% and males 22.8%) versus group B that includes patients operated on using the longitudinal incision (n = 194, female 70.1% and male 29.9%) in term of clinical satisfaction and safety. The mean age of group A is 58.1±5.1 and that of group B is 58.8±4.8. The male and female distribution in both groups and the mean age were both similar with no statistically significant difference for the age (p = 0.79) or the gender distribution (p = 0.1). Data collected prospectively at regular intervals in time (preoperatively and at one month, three months, and six months post-carpal tunnel release (CTR)) between January 2006 and December 2021 were reviewed retrospectively. Patients' clinical findings, grip strength measurement using a hand dynamometer, and postoperative satisfaction measured using the BCTQ (Boston Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Questionnaire) scoring system were recorded and analyzed for each technique.

A total of 415 patients were included in our study. All patients included had moderate to severe median nerve compression documented by nerve-conducted studies with positive Tinel's and Phalen's signs. Baseline demographics between group A (CTR through a longitudinal palmar mini-incision) and group B (CTR with a mini-transverse incision at the palmar crease) didn't show a statistically significant difference. Both groups showed improved grip strength and BCTQ scores at the post-operative follow-up.

Median nerve decompression using both types of incisions has resulted in the same functional outcomes and patient satisfaction.