Teaching of manual cataract extraction in ophthalmic surgical training programmes
Alexandra McCreery1, Amy O'Regan2, Noel Horgan2,3
1St Vincent's University Hospital, Dublin, Ireland. m.alexandramccreery@gmail.com.
Background:
Manual cataract extraction techniques such as extracapsular cataract extraction (ECCE) or manual small incision cataract (MSICS) surgery have been replaced by phacoemulsification cataract surgery. Surgical training opportunities for manual techniques of cataract extraction are limited in modern surgical training programmes.
Aims:
This study evaluated the current trends of ECCE/MSICS training opportunities amongst trainees and trainers in the Irish Ophthalmic Surgical Training Program.
Methods:
An electronic survey was distributed to all ophthalmic surgical trainees and consultants in the country. It addressed the experience and exposure to ECCE/MSICS.
Results:
Nineteen of 33 (57%) trainees and 29 of 55 (55%) of consultants completed the survey. Twelve of 19 (63%) trainees viewed an ECCE procedure performed live. Twenty-seven of 29 (93%) consultants performed an ECCE procedure during their surgical career; 8 of 27 (30%) performed an ECCE within the last 1-3 years. Fourteen of 19 (74%) trainees stated they do not feel confident converting from phacoemulsification to ECCE independently. Sixteen of 19 (89%) trainees believe manual cataract extraction training should be included in their surgical training. Nineteen of 29 (65%) consultants believe training in manual cataract extraction should be part of the surgical training programme.
Conclusions:
There is a paucity of manual cataract extraction being performed in Ireland, limiting live surgical training in this technique. This survey highlights the limited experience of trainees in this valuable skill that is occasionally required for a successful surgical outcome. The authors conclude that wet laboratory simulated training of manual cataract extraction will bridge this gap.
