The Cyborg Method: A Method to Identify Fraudulent Responses from Crowdsourced Data

Crowdsourcing is an essential data collection method for psychological research. Concerns about the validity and quality of crowdsourced data persist, however. A recent documented increase in the number of invalid responses within crowdsourced data has highlighted the need for quality control measures. Although a number of approaches are recommended, few have been empirically evaluated. The present study evaluated a Cyborg Method that used automated evaluation of participant meta-data and a review of short answer responses. Two samples were recruited - in the first, the Cyborg Method was applied after data collection to gauge the extent to which invalid responses were collected when a priori quality controls were absent. In the second, the Cyborg Method was applied during data collection to determine if the method would proactively screen invalid responses. Results suggested that Cyborg Method identified a substantial portion of invalid responses and both automated and human evaluation components was necessary. Furthermore, the Cyborg Method could be applied proactively to screen invalid responses and substantially reduced the per participant cost of data collection. These results suggest that the Cyborg Method is a promising means by which to collect high quality crowdsourced data.