Protection Against Infectious Bronchitis Virus Vaccine Recombinants and Chicken-Selected Vaccine Subpopulations

Outbreaks of infectious bronchitis (IB) continue to occur from novel variants of IB virus (IBV) emerging from selection of vaccine subpopulations and/or naturally occurring recombination events. S1 sequencing of Arkansas (Ark) -type viruses obtained from clinical cases in Alabama broilers and backyard chickens shows both Ark Delmarva Poultry Industry (ArkDPI) vaccine subpopulations as well as Ark vaccine viruses showing recombination with other IB vaccine viruses. IB Ark-type isolates AL5, most similar to an ArkDPI vaccine subpopulation selected in chickens, AL4, showing a cluster of three nonsynonymous changes from ArkDPI subpopulations selected in chickens, and AL9, showing recombination with Massachusetts (Mass) -type IBV, were examined for pathogenicity and ability to break through immunity elicited by vaccination with a commercial ArkDPI vaccine. Analysis of predicted S1 protein structures indicated the changes were in regions previously shown to comprise neutralizing epitopes. Thus, they were expected to contribute to immune escape and possibly virulence. Based on clinical signs, viral load, and histopathology, all three isolates caused disease in naïve chickens, although AL9 and AL5 viral loads in trachea were statistically significantly higher (30- and 40-fold) than AL4. S1 gene sequencing confirmed the stability of the relevant changes in the inoculated viruses in the chickens, although virus in some individual chickens exhibited additional S1 changes. A single amino acid deletion in the S1 NTD was identified in some individual chickens. The location of this deletion in the predicted structure of S1 suggested the possibility that it was a compensatory change for the reduced ability of AL4 to replicate in the trachea of naïve chickens. Chickens vaccinated with a commercial ArkDPI vaccine at day of hatch and challenged at 21 days of age showed that vaccination provided incomplete protection against challenge with these viruses. Moreover, based on viral RNA copy numbers in trachea, differences were detected in the ability of the vaccine to protect against these IBV isolates, with the vaccine protecting the most poorly against AL4. These results provide additional evidence supporting that IBV attenuated vaccines, especially ArkDPI vaccines, contribute to perpetuating the problem of IB in commercial chickens.