Diagnostic significance of clay-like materials aspirated from thyroid nodules

The simplest way to determine the adequacy of aspirated materials is the on-site gross visual assessment of aspirated materials. However, few studies have examined the gross findings of thyroid aspirates. This study aimed to clarify the diagnostic significance of clay-like material aspirated from thyroid nodules.

We reviewed 69,848 thyroid nodules that underwent aspiration cytology at Kuma Hospital between January 2007 and August 2021. Among them, 355 (0.5%) nodules with aspirated materials described as clay-like materials were retrospectively examined.

Among 355 nodules, 322 (90.7%) were categorized as cystic fluid or benign. The aspirated materials were mainly composed of non-epithelial components, including colloid or proteinaceous materials, foamy histiocytes, and degenerative red blood cells. In original ultrasound reports, the incidence of intermediate and high suspicion was 11.0%. Malignant cells were observed in 21 nodules (5.9%), one-third of which were papillary thyroid carcinomas. The materials aspirated from papillary and follicular thyroid carcinomas exhibited necrotic carcinoma cells derived from infarcted areas. The overall risk of malignancy was 3.9%. The risk of malignancy in nodules interpreted as highly suspicious on ultrasound examination was 37.5%.

As clay-like materials aspirated from thyroid nodules were considered sufficient specimens, the recognition contributes to avoiding unnecessary second punctures. The presence of clay-like materials was indicative of the colloid and/or blood components of benign cystic lesions, or, more rarely, of infarcted carcinoma. The ultrasound examination results tended to overestimate nodules. We should reaffirm that on-site gross visual assessment of aspirated materials is a fast and reasonably accurate predictor of the on-site adequacy of the samples.