Hip Surgery is Not More Painful Than Spine Surgery in Children With Cerebral Palsy

Posterior spinal fusion (PSF) and hip reconstruction are commonly indicated surgeries in children with cerebral palsy (CP), particularly those functioning at GMFCS levels IV and V. These are large and often painful procedures, and previous literature suggests that hip surgery is more painful than spine surgery in this patient population. The purpose of this study is to investigate pain scores and opioid use following hip and spine surgery in a large cohort of children with CP, including many patients who have undergone both types of surgery.

A retrospective chart review was performed to identify children with CP who underwent hip reconstruction and/or PSF at a tertiary children's hospital between 2004 and 2022. Charts were reviewed for demographic data, pain scores, pain medication usage, duration of hospital stay, and complications.

Data were collected for 200 patients (101 male, 99 female) who met inclusion criteria. Eighty-seven patients underwent hip reconstruction, 62 spinal fusion, and 51 both hip and spine surgery asynchronously. Median (interquartile range) age at the time of surgery was significantly older for spinal fusion compared with hip surgery [13.1 (4.9) vs. 8.1 (5.7) y, P <0.0001]. Length of stay was significantly longer after PSF, with a median of 6 (4) days compared with 2 (1) days after hip surgery ( P <0.0001). Both maximum and average daily pain scores were similar following hip and spine surgery, with the exception that average pain scores for hip surgery were slightly higher on postoperative day 1, hip=1.73 vs. spine=1.0 ( P <0.0001). The amount of opioids used, expressed as morphine milligram equivalents (MME)/kg were similar in the hip and spine surgery groups; however, it was significantly lower in the hip surgery group on postoperative day 0, hip=0.06 versus spine=0.17 ( P <0.0001). For the 51 patients who underwent both hip and spine surgery, the amount of opioids used mirrored that for the entire group (similar MME/kg, though only statistically significantly less on POD 0 and 3), and pain scores were not significantly different between the 2 groups except in 2 circumstances. The 2 exceptions in these 51 patients both demonstrated lower pain scores in patients after hip surgery, including lower maximum pain scores on POD 1 ( P =0.041), and lower average pain scores on POD3 ( P =0.043).

This is the largest series to date comparing postoperative pain in children with CP after hip and spine surgery, including 51 of 200 patients who underwent both types of surgery. The results of this study demonstrate that hip surgery is not more painful than spine surgery in children with CP, and conflict with the traditional belief that hip surgery is more painful. This is important information for health care providers when counseling patients and families regarding these surgeries in children with CP.

Level 3.