Low Valence Triel (I) Systems as Hydrogen Bond Acceptors and their Stability with Respect to Triel (III) Compounds

A theoretical study of the complexes formed by carbene like Al(I), Ga(I), In(I) and Tl(I) compounds with hydrogen bond donors (HBD), XH (HCCH, HSH,HOH, HCN, HCl, HBr, HF, and HNC) have been carried out at MP2 computational level. The isolated triel(I) compounds show a negative region of the molecular electrostatic potential region associated with the triel atom suitable to interact with electron deficient groups. This region is associated to a lone pair based on the ELF analysis and to the location of the HOMO orbital. The complexes are similar to those found in nitrogen heterocyclic carbenes (NHC) with HBD. In addition, the oxidative addition reactions of those complexes to yield the corresponding valence III compounds have been characterized. The Al(III) compounds are much more stable than the corresponding Al(I) complexes. However, the stability of the triel(III) compounds decreases with the size of the triel atom and for the thallium derivatives, the Tl(I) complexes are more stable than the Tl(III) compounds in accordance with the number of the structures found in the CSD. The barrier of the TS connecting the triel(I) and triel(III) systems increases with the size of the triel atoms.