Energy-based devices and hyaluronic acid filler, polymer filler, and threads: Cadaveric study

The objective of this experiment was to investigate the thermal effects on hyaluronic acid fillers, PCL fillers, and PDO threads when exposed to controlled heat. This study aims to provide insights into how these materials respond to thermal energy, which is crucial for safe and effective cosmetic procedures involving combined modalities.

Cadaveric tissue was utilized to simulate clinical conditions. Hyaluronic acid fillers were injected at approximately 1 mm and 5 mm thicknesses, with variations in G' value (high and low). PCL fillers were similarly injected in 1 mm and 5 mm thicknesses. PDO threads were also inserted. All materials were injected at a depth of 2 cm. A thermometer was used to measure heat penetration, and a multi-wavelength laser was applied to the tissue. The temperature was maintained at 60°C for 5 min to assess whether heat penetrated more than 3 cm in thickness. Observations were made regarding the heat distribution and any physical changes in the fillers and threads.

In thick layers, heat accumulated above the PCL filler without penetrating deeper layers. In thin layers, heat penetration was observed. For the HA fillers, heat energy was not blocked, regardless of the G' value or thickness. For the threads, no significant heat blockage effect was observed. For all materials, no visual changes were detected in any of the materials due to temperature exposure.

The findings suggest that the thickness and composition of fillers significantly influence heat penetration. Thick PCL fillers act as a thermal barrier, whereas thin PCL fillers allow deeper heat penetration. Hyaluronic acid fillers do not impede heat transfer, regardless of their physical properties. PDO threads do not exhibit any notable thermal resistance. These insights are essential for optimizing the safety and efficacy of combined filler and energy-based device treatments in esthetic medicine.