Performance of Modification of Diet in Renal Disease and Chronic Kidney Disease Epidemiology Collaboration Equations...

To evaluate the performance of measurement of glomerular filtration rate (GFR) using Modification of Diet in Renal Disease equations (MDRD186, MDRD175) and Chronic Kidney Disease Epidemiology Collaboration (CKD-EPI) equations, in comparison with technetium-99m diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (⁹⁹Tc-DTPA) renogram method, the gold standard. A related aim was to correlate the three equations to estimate GFR and their impact on reclassifying the stages of CKD in adult Omani patients.

This cross-sectional study recruited two groups of patients diagnosed with CKD during a 10-month period from January to October 2021. The first group comprised 48 patients who underwent a ⁹⁹Tc-DTPA renogram procedure for GFR measurement, and the second group comprised 30 348 adult patients who did not undergo the same procedure; estimated GFR was calculated using the three equations.

The median of the reference GFR was 106.0 mL/min/1.73 m², whereas the median estimated GFR for the MDRD175, MDRD186, and CKD-EPI equations were 92.5, 98.3, and 102.1, respectively. All three equations correlated moderately with the reference GFR (0.428, 0.428, 0.523, respectively; p < 0.010). The CKD-EPI showed lesser bias (3.7 vs. 12.9 and 7.5 for MDRD175 and MDRD186, respectively) and more accuracy (95.8% vs. 91.7% and 93.8%); however, it was the least precise (25.1 vs. 22.3 and 23.8). The MDRD186 performed similarly to the CKD-EPI equation at CKD stages 3a-5 and differed significantly at stages 1-2. Whereas the MDRD175 differed significantly with both equations at stages 1-3b and was similar to them at stages 4-5.

The CKD-EPI equation had the highest accuracy and the least bias and precision in the general population. The MDRD186 CKD classification differed significantly from the CKD-EPI equation at CKD-stages 1-2 only. The CKD-EPI equation is preferred to MDRD for the detection and classification of early CKD stages.