Multi-decadal geochemical evolution of drainage from underground coal mines in the Appalachian basin, USA

Coal mine drainage (CMD) in Appalachia is a widespread source of dissolved metals, SO₄, and acidity that can degrade aquatic habitats and water supplies for decades following mine closure and flooding. In the bituminous coalfield of Pennsylvania, the Irwin Coal Basin (ICB) contains a series of partly to completely flooded, abandoned underground mines separated by leaky barriers within the Pittsburgh coal seam. CMD originated throughout the basin from minepool aquifers that formed after mine closures dating from 1910 to 1957. Historical and recent water quality data for eight CMD sites across the ICB, plus mineralogy and cation-exchange capacity of overburden lithologies, were analyzed to quantify important reactants and evaluate spatial and temporal water-quality trends. As overburden thickness and residence time increase along a ~ 50-km flowpath northeast to southwest in the basin, CMD becomes more alkaline, and Na concentrations increase. Since the 1970s, all eight ICB discharges have become less acidic, with exponential decreases in acidity, SO₄, and Fe concentrations; only two CMD remain net-acidic (acidic pH at equilibrium). Exponential decay models that include a steady-state asymptote consistent with background groundwater chemistry and siderite equilibrium describe the early-stage, rapid contaminant concentration decay immediately after the "first flush" (initial flooding) and the progressive evolution toward late-stage background conditions. A geochemical evolution PHREEQC model indicates that spatial and temporal trends in pH, net-acidity, SO₄, Fe, and major cations could be explained by the continuous dilution of first flush water by ambient groundwater combined with sustained water-mineral reactions involving pyrite and carbonates (calcite, dolomite, siderite) plus cation-exchange by clays (illite, chlorite, mixed-layer illite/smectite). These data and model results indicate that 1) cation-exchange reactions enhance calcite dissolution and alkalinity production, resulting in the evolution of CMD to Na-SO₄-HCO₃ type waters, and 2) siderite equilibrium could maintain dissolved Fe >16 mg/L over the next 40 years.