Hormonal dynamics of matrotrophy vs. lecithotrophy in live-bearing fish reproduction

We explored the relationship between gestational states, fecundity, and steroid hormone levels in three species of live-bearing fish with different maternal provisioning strategies. We studied two lecithotrophic species, Gambusia affinis and Xiphophorus couchianus, where embryos feed exclusively on yolk stored in the eggs, and one matrotrophic species, Heterandria formosa, which actively transfers nutrients to embryos through a follicular placenta. We measured water-borne cortisol, estradiol, and progesterone along with brood size (fecundity) and gestational stage(s). We examined the physiological costs of both maternal provisioning modes. Matrotrophy likely imposes energetic demands due to active nutrient transfer, while lecithotrophy may incur costs from carrying many large embryos. We hypothesized that fecundity, gestational stage, and hormones would covary differently in lecithotrophic vs. matrotrophic species. We found no relationships between hormones and fecundity or gestational stage in any species. However, in H. formosa, we found a positive relationship between estradiol levels and female mass, and a negative relationship between progesterone levels and female mass indicating a change in the circulating levels of both hormones as females grow. We observed differences in average hormone levels among species: the matrotrophic species had higher progesterone and lower estradiol compared to lecithotrophic species. Higher estradiol in lecithotrophic species may relate to egg yolk formation, while placental structures could play a role in progesterone production in matrotrophic species. Elevated cortisol in H. formosa suggests either higher energetic costs or a preparative role for reproduction. Our findings highlight progesterone's importance in maintaining gestation in matrotrophic species, like other placental species.