Examining site intervention efficacy and uncertainties with conceptual Bayesian networks: preventing offsite...

For contaminated sites, conceptual site models (CSMs) guide the assessment and management of risks, including remediation strategies. Recent research has expanded diagrammatic CSMs with structural causal modeling to develop what are nominally called conceptual Bayesian networks (CBNs) for environmental risk assessment. These CBNs may also be useful for problems of controlling and preventing offsite contaminant migration, especially for sites containing dense nonaqueous phase liquids (DNAPLs). In particular, the CBNs provide greater clarity on the causal relationships between source term, onsite and offsite migration, and remediation effectiveness characterization for contaminated DNAPL sites compared to traditional CSMs. These ideas are demonstrated by the inclusion of modifying variables, causal pathway analysis, and interventions in CBNs. Additionally, several new extensions of the CBN concept are explored including the representation of measurement variables as lines of evidence and alignment with conventional pictorial CSMs for groundwater modeling. Taken as a whole, the CBNs provide a powerful and adaptable knowledge representation tool for remediating subsurface systems contaminated by DNAPL.