The effect of positional changes on oxygenation in patients with pleural effusions

In unilateral parenchymal pulmonary disease, arterial oxygenation decreases when the patient is positioned such that the abnormal lung is dependent; however, few studies have evaluated the effect of the body position on oxygenation in patients with unilateral or asymmetric pleural effusions. To our knowledge, no previous study has evaluated the possible transient effects of changing position on the level of arterial oxygen saturation (SaO2) in such patients. Accordingly, we studied ten normoxic patients spontaneously breathing room air, who had asymmetric pleural effusions as documented by chest x-ray film and physical examination. We monitored pulse, respiratory rate, and blood pressure every five minutes and SaO2 by ear oximetry continuously while patients were in the following positions: sitting; supine; and left and right lateral decubitus. The mean SaO2 was 95 percent and 94.3 percent in the sitting and supine positions, respectively. Mean SaO2 fell to 93.4 percent when the patients were positioned so that the side with the largest pleural effusion was dependent. When the side with the pleural effusion was down, the mean SaO2 was significantly lower than in either the sitting position or with the side with the pleural effusion up. We could find no significant relationship between the size of the pleural effusion and the amount of arterial oxygen desaturation. We conclude that there is a decrease in SaO2 in normoxic patients when the side with the larger pleural effusion is dependent; however, this decreased SaO2 does not appear to be clinically significant in patients with normal SaO2.