Vascularization of Human Acellular Dermal Matrices: A Comparative Study in a Nonhuman Primate Model

Four human acellular dermal matrices (hADMs) were characterized in a nonhuman primate abdominal wall repair model by evaluating host immune response, vascularization, and incorporation into host tissues. AlloDerm™ (electron beam-sterilized hADM [e-hADM]), AlloMax™ (gamma beam-sterilized hADM, freeze-dried [g-hADM-FD]), DermaMatrix™ (hADM, freeze-dried [hADM-FD]), and FlexHD™ (ethanol-treated hADM [EtOH-hADM]) were each implanted in an abdominal wall-bridging defect in nonhuman primates (n = 3 animals/time point, n = 36 animals). Immunohistochemical and histological assessments were conducted on biopsies from each hADM at 1-, 3-, and 6-months postimplantation to assess vascularization (hematoxylin and eosin [H&E], CD31, alpha smooth muscle actin [αSMA], collagen IV), inflammatory/immune response (H&E, CD3, CD20, CD68), and collagen turnover (H&E, matrix metalloproteinase-9 [MMP-9]). MMP-9 immunolabeling was similar among different hADMs at 1 month; however, hADM-FD and EtOH-hADM showed higher total mean MMP-9-immunopositive areas at approximately 16% compared with <1% for e-hADM and g-hADM at 6 months postimplantation. Cells that stained positively for CD68, CD3, and CD20 were generally higher for hADM-FD and EtOH-hADM compared with other hADMs. The mean CD31-immunopositive area, CD31 vessel density, CD31 vessel diameter, and collagen IV-immunopositive area increased over time. Among all the hADM types, e-hADM had the highest mean (±standard deviation [SD]) CD31-immunopositive area at 1.54% ± 1.01%, vessel density at 7.86 × 10^-5 ± 3.96 × 10^-5 vessels/µm², and collagen IV-immunopositive area at 2.55% ± 0.73% 1-month postimplantation. The pattern of αSMA immunolabeling varied among the hADMs. Histology showed that overall inflammation was mild at 1 month. Overall fibroblast repopulation and collagen remodeling increased over time from 1 to 6 months postimplantation. Fibroblast infiltration was minimal to mild at 1 month, with e-hADM showing the highest mean (±SD) score at 2.00 ± 0.00 compared with other hADMs. Only hADM-FD was not completely replaced by neotissue formation at 6 months postimplantation. All hADMs promoted vascularization, cell infiltration, and incorporation into host tissue, which were associated with acute inflammation and immune responses, within a 6-month period. A trend toward relatively enhanced early vascularization in e-hADM compared with other hADMs was observed. Immunogenic responses among the hADMs in the present study showed a slight distinction toward more quiescent terminally sterilized hADMs (e-hADM, g-hADM-FD) versus aseptically processed hADMs (EtOH-hADM, hADM-FD).