Rapid nucleation and optimal surface-ligand interaction stabilize wurtzite MnSe

Non-native structures (NNS) differ in discrete translational symmetry from the bulk ground state native structure (NS). To explore the extent of deconvolution of various factors relevant to the stabilization of the wurtzite/NNS of MnSe via a heat-up method, we performed experiments using various ligands (oleic acid, oleylamine, octadecylamine, stearic acid, and octadecene), solvents (tetraethylene glycol and octadecene), and precursor salts (manganese chloride and manganese acetate). Experiments suggest that oleic acid in the presence of tetraethylene glycol and oleylamine in the presence of octadecene stabilize wurtzite/NNS. Further, density functional theory (DFT) computations explore the interaction between the functional groups in ligands and the most exposed surfaces of wurtzite/NNS and rocksalt/NS polymorphs. Computations suggest that the interactions between relevant surface facets with carboxylic acid and the double bond functional groups suppress the phase transformation from NNS to NS. In addition, the ionizability of the precursor salt also determines the rate of formation of the metal-ligand complex and the rate of nucleation. Consequently, the formation rate of the Mn-ligand complex is expected to be greater in the case of chloride salt than acetate salt because the chloride salt has higher ionizability in ethylene glycol. From the above, we conclude that the kinetics of the wurtzite/NNS to rocksalt/NS phase transformation depends mainly on two factors: (1) nucleation/growth kinetics which is controlled by the ionizability of the precursor salt, solvent, and stability of the metal-ligand complex, and (2) the activation energy barrier of the NNS to NS conversion which is controlled by surface energy minimization with the ligand.