Primary Total Hip Arthroplasty Outcomes for Labral Tears are Comparable to Advanced Osteoarthritis

There is a paucity of evidence on outcomes following total hip arthroplasty (THA) in patients who have symptomatic degenerative labral tears and mild to moderate osteoarthritis (OA). The purpose of this study was to determine if outcomes of primary THA in the setting of painful, symptomatic labral tear and mild to moderate arthritic changes were comparable to outcomes of primary THA performed for severe arthritic changes. Primary outcomes were patient-reported outcome (PRO) scores. Secondary outcomes included length of stay and perioperative complications.

This was a retrospective investigation of all THAs between January 2018 and July 2022. There were 111 patients who had THA due to failure of nonoperative treatment of a degenerative labral tear without advanced arthritic changes (mild to moderate OA cohort, Kellgren-Lawrence Grades 1 to 3). These patients were matched to 111 patients who underwent THA for advanced OA (AOA cohort, Kellgren-Lawrence Grade 4). PROs included the Western Ontario McMaster Universities Arthritis Index (WOMAC). The average age for the labral tear cohort was 59 years, with 50.6% women, compared to 70 years (P < 0.001), and 49.4% women (P = 0.93) in the AOA cohort.

There were no differences in preoperative PROs, complications, or length of stay between groups. When looking at postoperative PROs between cohorts, the labral tear cohort had less improvement in WOMAC-Stiffness (24.3 versus 34.0, P = 0.005) and WOMAC-Functional limitation (26.3 versus 36.0, P = 0.005) at 12 months and greater improvement in WOMAC-Pain at 12 months (38.3 versus 34.7, P = 0.04). The Short Form 12-Physical function scores were significantly higher among the labral tear cohort compared to the AOA cohort at 12 months (48.5 versus 47.8, P < 0.001). The Short Form 12-Mental scores were significantly higher in the AOA cohort compared to the labral tear cohort at 3 months (47.1 versus 47.4, P = 0.02) and 12 months (46.7 versus 47.6, P < 0.001). In the multivariate analysis, the change in WOMAC-Pain at 12 months was significantly better for labral tear patients (odds ratio 7.5, P = 0.008, confidence interval 6.85 to 8.14).

Our study showed that patients who have symptomatic degenerative labral tears with mild to moderate arthritic changes have comparable outcomes to patients who have AOA following primary THA. Given suboptimal outcomes with hip arthroscopy for labral tear in the setting of early arthritis, primary THA can be a reasonable treatment modality for patients failing nonoperative treatments.