Right vs. Left colorectal cancer - Where do we draw the line?

No consensus on the definition of right and left colorectal cancer (CRC) exists, nor studies offering histological or molecular basis for such categorisation. This study investigated the regional variations in the histological and molecular characteristics of CRCs, with the objective of determining an optimal division point between right and left CRCs.

An observational study of consecutive patients who underwent CRC resection (1995-2022) at Concord Hospital, Sydney was performed. Clinicopathological data were extracted from a prospective database and seven permutations of right-left divisions considered. Logistic regression tested association between the right-left divisions and pathological characteristics. Receiver operating characteristic and area under the curve (AUC) analyses determined the discriminative ability of each division to predict 18 pathology characteristics.

3753 patients underwent a CRC resection (2120 male; mean 69.5yrs [SD12.6]). There was regional variation in tumours with respect to tumour infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs), mismatch repair deficiency (dMMR), and mutant BRAF (mBRAF). Left-sided tumours were less likely to demonstrate TILs (P < 0.001), be dMMR (P < 0.001), and express mBRAF (P < 0.001). Division at the descending-sigmoid junction yielded highest discriminative abilities: TILs - AUC 0.66, dMMR - AUC 0.76, and mBRAF - AUC 0.73.

This is the first study to provide a pathological basis on which right- and left-sided cancers may be defined, and found the optimal division point between the right and left colorectum to be at the descending-sigmoid junction. Further research is needed to determine whether this can facilitate individualised patient management.