A Comparative Study of Principled rPPG-Based Pulse Rate Tracking Algorithms for Fitness Activities

Performance improvements obtained by recent principled approaches for pulse rate (PR) estimation from face videos have typically been achieved by adding or modifying certain modules within a reconfigurable system. Yet, evaluations of such remote photoplethysmography (rPPG) are usually performed only at the system level. To better understand each module's contribution and facilitate future research in explainable learning and artificial intelligence for physiological monitoring, this paper conducts a comparative study of video-based, principled PR tracking algorithms, with a focus on challenging fitness scenarios. A review of the progress achieved over the last decade and a half in this field is utilized to construct the major processing modules of a reconfigurable remote pulse rate sensing system. Experiments are conducted on two challenging datasets-an internal collection of 25 videos of two Asian males exercising on stationary-bike, elliptical, and treadmill machines and 34 videos from a public ECG fitness database of 14 men and 3 women exercising on elliptical and stationary-bike machines. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), Pearson's correlation coefficient, error count ratio, error rate, and root mean squared error are used for performance evaluation. The top-performing configuration produces respective values of 0.8 dB, 0.86, 9%, 1.7%, and 3.3 beats per minute (bpm) for the internal dataset and 1.3 dB, 0.77, 28.6%, 6.0%, and 8.1 bpm for the ECG Fitness dataset, achieving significant improvements over alternative configurations. Our results suggest a synergistic effect between pulse color mapping and adaptive motion filtering, as well as the importance of a robust frequency tracking algorithm for PR estimation in low SNR settings.