Is zero more than nothing? Relations between concepts of zero and integer understanding

The concept of zero is challenging for many children. This study investigated conceptions of zero in fifth- through seventh-grade children (N = 72) in the United States and examined how children's conceptions of zero related to other aspects of their integer knowledge. At the outset of the study, many participants held a null conception of zero (i.e., zero as "nothing"), and some participants held a conception of zero as the symmetry point between the positive and negative integers. Participants in higher grades were more likely to hold a symmetry conception. We hypothesized that participants' conceptions of zero would be related to other aspects of their integer knowledge. Relative to participants who held a null conception of zero, participants who held a symmetry conception demonstrated greater knowledge of the additive inverse principle (for every number x, there exists an inverse, -x, such that the two numbers sum to zero) and greater integer arithmetic skill. Conceptions of zero were not related to integer magnitude understanding. We also examined whether a brief lesson focusing on zero as the symmetry point would lead to shifts in participants' conceptions of zero and gains in understanding of the additive inverse principle. Participants were randomly assigned to receive a lesson about zero as null or zero as the symmetry point between positive and negative integers. Relative to the lesson about zero as null, the lesson about zero as the symmetry point did not lead to substantial changes in conceptions of zero or additive inverse knowledge.